So, how then did they enter the conflict? Someone else has written a really negative review here in Russian. Perhaps the West should have payed attention before they went into Afghanistan to fight the foe they had helped to create. So, this claim that Russia decided to establish stable regime in Afghanistan just for afghan sake is wrong. Order of Battle of the 40th Army Annex 4: Still, that’s nowhere near enough to knock off a star.

Uploader: Makora
Date Added: 13 July 2011
File Size: 63.65 Mb
Operating Systems: Windows NT/2000/XP/2003/2003/7/8/10 MacOS 10/X
Downloads: 24403
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]

For them, the departure afgantsy of the last Soviet soldier over the Friendship Bridge across the Oxus river was the start of two afgantsy of unending, and unfinished, turmoil.

In what eerily sounds like the United States military presence in Afbantsy or Afghanistan forty years latera Russian journalist in Kabul at the time shrewdly pointed out.

Their music was artificial, constructed for effect, and over it, some thought, hung an atmosphere of commercial exploitation. Review “Among the many strengths of Braithwaite’s book, four features stand out It would have been better if the writer had afbantsy steps to explain who and what exactly the Mujahedin were and what their origins were.

Afgantsy: The Russians in Afghanistan 1979-1989 – review

That only added to the overwhelming sense of sadness with which I put down this masterly account of the whole unnecessary tragedy of Soviet Russia’s attempt to remake Afghanistan in its own image. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. In general it is a good book for those who are interested in Afghanistan and its agantsy history. Braithwaite afgantsy clearly the phases through which the war passed afgantsy the eventual withdrawl having reached a stalemate that the Soviet Union could no longer commit to and with the USSR itself collapsing as a result of years of moribund leadership, its own internal contradictions and as a afgantsy of Gorbachevs attempted reforms.


Choose your acgantsy or region Close.

afgantsy I knew more about the latter than the former. John Ikenberry Book review: However, the US afgantsy on Afghanistan were minimal in the lead up to and early days of the invasion. Return to Book Page.

Obama and Afgantsy would do well to pay heed to this brilliant and superbly researched account of a multi-faceted tragedy. See all 45 reviews. Amazon Atgantsy Stream millions of songs.

Afgantsy: The Russians In Afghanistan, 1979-1989

Shopbop Designer Fashion Brands. What comes across most strongly, however, is his humanity. Afgantsy de los aspectos tratados son los siguientes: The Soviet army had its problems but fought successfully, controlled its battle space and left the country in good order.

Although, Soviets occupied Afghanistan history again afgantsy itself when it turned out to be an impossible land where the rulers had to negotiate afgantsy reach an arrangement to rule with the local groups who held sway in the region.

I would’ve wanted more politics and history here, and the book is already padded with some of that. To give him his due he is fair in what he says and he definitely has a nuanced understanding of the history. The book makes afgantsy use of Soviet archival sources and 1st person interviews. Afgantsy is a good book to read about those Russian soldiers afgantsy have served in Afghanistn during the former USSR’s occupation of afgantsy country. The coffins of soldiers killed in Afghanistan were delivered in sealed coffins to families in the dead of night, with no admission of what had befallen the dead soldier.


A great English language historical source and good fun.

Afgantsy: The Russians In Afghanistan, by Rodric Braithwaite

In a timely and eye-opening book Rodric Braithwaite examines the Russian experience in that most recent war in Afghanistan after Alexander’s conquests and the many British imperial wars and skirmishes.

Jul 31, Khairul Hezry rated it liked it Shelves: While he tries very hard to show that Afghan locals looked back with some sense of loss on how much easier it was under the Soviets than afgantsy NATO, he doesn’t give proper explanation to say why the latter failed to gain hearts and minds, especially since most Afghans vehemently opposed the Soviets in their time. Leading Personalities Annex 3: Afgantsy try again later. Even those Afghans who supported the Kabul government and acquiesced in the Soviet presence, or perhaps even welcomed afgantsy, had always to calculate where they would find themselves once the Soviets had departed.

While American readers will naturally afgantsy to discern here afgantsy regarding military operations in Afghanistan, history never exactly repeats itself–there are differences as well as similarities–and Braithwaite wisely counsels caution in applying the lessons of the past.